Many times I've seen the topic of the Great Label Debate on blogs. Who to order from? I ordered from 2 places and had good luck with both.
I first ordered these from Namemaker.com. They have several choices of color, size, and motif, but limited fonts. These are 3/8". I wish I had ordered a different style, but they are okay. Take them for their word that delivery will be within 4-6 weeks. Mine arrived after 5 weeks. I bought 100 labels for $35.60 ($5.60 was shipping). I ordered and didn't hear from them until the labels arrived. Nice quality labels.
These are from FancyWeaver on ebay. They will make your label with any free font and just about any color combination. When I sent payment I put all the information for the labels (name, color, font) in the notes section. They emailed a mock up of the labels the next day. They arrived from Hong Kong registered mail in 8 days. I spent $35 (including shipping) for 200 labels. Nice quality labels. I like these much better.